This week’s article comes from freelance non-formal education trainer and consultant Carmine Rodi Falanga. This blog was originally posted in Carmine’s own blog “To Say Nothing of the Cat.” – https://carminerodi.wordpress.com/
This is a short summary of what happened in the summer 2014, when I went to Tanzania to take part to “Insight”, a fantastic project organised by the Irish friends at Development Perspectives with Uvikiuta in Tanzania.
Insight is a year-long learning programme on Global Education that takes part in Ireland and Tanzania. It involves students (no real age requirement, from college up) from both countries taking part in an exciting process based on three parts: 1) preparation of the Irish group, in Ireland; 2) experiential phase, when both groups meet in Tanzania and work on a joint project; 3) when both groups meet back in Ireland, to evaluate the project and promote its results.
Now, let’s make things clear: it’s not one of those programmes “oh, let’s go and help the poor Africans to get developed”. Quite the contrary. It’s been conceived from the beginning as a horizontal learning programme with no hierarchy, where all people involved learn from each other, namely about global issues and on how to deal with prejudice(s), but first and foremost about themselves. This is actually the main reason why I am happy – and very proud – to be involved in it. In 2014 I had the privilege of taking part in stage 2 in Tanzania, together with my wife Bara, and I am not afraid to say that that was one experience that has changed our life. Such is the power of the programme.
First of all, it was my first time in sub-Saharian Africa. It’s not an overstatement to say that it really is another world. On so many levels. Going so far really does put many things in another perspective: what we consider “normal”, or “nature”, just to name two elements. Economics, development, education, religion, history, food… everything comes in the picture, really, and I had so many moments of Insight – exactly – really, the title of the programme couldn’t be more appropriate. I was (supposed to be) one of the trainers and facilitators of the intercultural process, but I was so humbled by the vastity of everything that happened there, that in the end I consider myself lucky I could simply take part to it. Never mind to contribute, a little bit.
The group took part in a strong preparation phase, and I joined them in one of the residential weekends (of which I seem to have kept no photo, sorry guys!) in Ireland. We tackled all the main programme details and a lot of practicalities, plus worked on topics such as communication, teamwork, project work. I even managed to slip through a condensed version of the Hero’s Journey walk (this part was to be repeated, in the 2015 edition, in its full glory).
Then it was time to depart to Tanzania. It was June-July 2014. I honestly felt challenged in so many levels, it was for me like being abroad again for the first time.Familiar expressions like “comfort zone” and “prejudice” acquired a stronger, new meaning and I found myself surprised again and again with my own feelings and reactions.
Walking alone at night in the camp at Morogoro, for example. It was a tiny village quite far from the nearest city, and we lived close to a local community of Maasai. I honestly think I was as safe as I could possibly be. And yet, how did I feel? I surprised myself wondering about it (and I am still ashamed of it). Also, the feeling of being “different”, and “the stranger” (mzungo, in Swahili): the only white guy in a bus, or walking down a street, for example. The simple colour of my skin was telling out more things about myself, than I was willing to express. It put A LOT of things in perspective. How do the immigrants feel in Europe, for example? Vulnerable, lost, “alien” as I felt at times?
Another strong emotion I became acquainted with goes under the name of “White Guilt”. I still have contrasting feelings about it. It basically implies that one, confronted with the high level of inequality present worldwide – starts feeling guilty just because of one’s geographical provenience.
I know I shouldn’t feel responsible for what Europeans did in the past – and in so many cases, are still doing. Or at least, not guilty. But I did. I do! And I cannot stop thinking that the level of privilege and the high standard of life we enjoy in the so-called “West” are owed, in considerable part, to the robberies and violence that have been committed in the past towards a huge number of people from other countries. It certainly goes on today. This is simply a new level of awareness that I cannot un-learn.
In many aspects, areas of Africa are still the world’s garbage dump. Materially, socially, economically. And not only of the western world: nowadays, even an occasional traveller will see the results of Chinese neo-colonialism there. I didn’t want to document this on pictures, because I don’t think it would do a fair service to the wonderful people I met on my journey. But the evidence is there, and it’s shocking.Slavery is abolished, apartheid is a thing of the past, but let’s just say this: there is still a lot of work to do. On ourselves.
Or, to mention another case. A simple question I ask myself, every day: “what do I fancy eating for lunch?“. Just in my neighbourhood I can choose between so many options. It’s time to acknowledge that too is a privilege, sometimes a shameless one. What is the cost that I inflict on the planet, and on other people, every time I order a specialty from another continent? Or I buy myself just another pair of sport shoes produced in Indonesia? That, too, is a realisation that is now an integral part of me. A true Insight.
But enough with the guilt card. Insight for me was also much, much more.
We visited two different camps. One was near Mbeya, a city some 800 kms west of Dar Es Salaam, very close to the Zambian border.
From there, we moved on to the second camp, in a tiny village near Morogoro, in a community that lived in close contact with a traditional Maasai village.
To be there, immersed full time into a totally different culture allowed me to really appreciate it in all its aspects. History, religions, economics, politics, I managed to get new points of view on all of it. It was a real intercultural learning experience.
First of all, what I did not see: the extreme poverty. Yes, a lot of people there live a simple life. Compared to some of the western standards. But forget the shocking pictures we associate to the notion of “Africa” sometimes. That story is also true but it doesn’t apply everywhere, just as there are huge differences in the standard of living across Europe, America, and everywhere else.
Tanzania has enjoyed peace and stability ever since its foundation in the sixties, and has had no major internal conflict. Not an easy achievement, since it comprises more than 120 ethnic groups.
Sure, it’s had its share of tensions (and suffered a military aggression by Idi Amin‘s brutal regime in Uganda, which left scars that are still all but solved), but its relative prosperity is owed in most part to the enlightened vision of Julius Nyerere, it’s historical president still revered as Father of the Nation. The country is rich with natural resources, and agriculture prospers. People are happy to be born there, happy to live there and praise its natural beauties even in the national anthem – it really is a place blessed by all gods, as I will widely document in one (or rather two) future posts.
They don’t even think about crossing the sea and putting their lives in danger to come to the “dreamed Europe”. I know because I asked them. The answer was “maybe yes, to study for a while. But I want to live and make a difference here“.
Did you hear that, Salvini – Le Pen – Cameron – Trump (etc)? You can sleep safe tonight, for there is no imminent danger of invasion from a country that enjoys economic, social and political stability. Surprise, surprise.
And more importantly: what I recorded without any trace left of doubt is that people from all parts of the world are just the same. No matter what is their education, background, religious belief or political history. Parents want a better future for their kids, and are ready to do utter sacrifices to obtain it – as I remember in particular from the life stories of our taxi driver in Dar Es Salaam, and of the wonderful man who took me and Bara on a walking safari near the Manyara Lake.
And young people? They want to get an education, to travel, and to have a possibility to shape their future. I was shocked breathless by the honest question a student asked me: “Do you have tribes, in Europe?”. It was coming from a brilliant young man, very competent and who could speak fluently several languages (including English). And after my initial surprise, of course I realised “but why should he know about our specific history in Europe? What do I know about his?”. Anyway, I must have answered something like “Well… we had, but we kind of wiped them out long time ago. Now all that’s left are football teams”.
And lastly, that every community cares for their elderly and those in need – I have witnessed deep acts of compassion and generosity even in poor areas – and in general,people just want to get on with their lives.
Now. As I write, applications are open for Insight 2016.
I am very happy to say that I will probably be able to join this fantastic initiative in 2016, too.
So, if you are reading these lines (and you are from Ireland or Tanzania, I am afraid that’s all the options at the moment), contact Development Perspectives and apply for what can really be an experience that will change your life. As it changed mine, for sure.
For further inspiration, you can watch the full documentary realised after Insight 2015, entirely on youtube: